*
A pumpkin pie beside an open plain bakery box on an oak dining table, with cream dishes and soft autumn window light.

Where West Akron Can Still Order Thanksgiving Pies and Dinners This Week

Mustard Seed Market took its last Thanksgiving turkey orders yesterday, Wednesday, Nov. 18. Whole roasted turkeys came only from its Montrose store. At 2303 West Market St., The West Side Bakery takes pie orders until Saturday.

Thanksgiving ordering on the west side of Akron doesn't close on one date. It closes over about a week. The grocery counters with the longest lists close first. A bakery that has been on West Market since 1995 and an Italian restaurant on White Pond Drive stay open through the weekend. Then come a couple of Wednesday deadlines and a Merriman Valley restaurant that hands over dinner on Thanksgiving Day. If you haven't settled your table yet, work through the list by date.

The deadlines closing this week

Most of this week's Thanksgiving advice comes from the Akron Beacon Journal's Nov. 14 roundup of Akron-area take-out feasts, and several of its deadlines are now closed. Marigold Catering on Front Street in Cuyahoga Falls stopped taking orders at the end of the day on Nov. 16. Mustard Seed and Giant Eagle both closed Nov. 18. Acme Fresh Market, Seven Grains Natural Market in Tallmadge and Hudson's Restaurant and Catering all have Nov. 19 deadlines, so today is the last day for each. Heinen's takes online turkey dinner orders through Friday, Nov. 20.

If none of those worked out, you still have a full weekend.

Saturday, Nov. 21: The West Side Bakery

The West Side Bakery says on its 2026 Thanksgiving menu that the last day to place orders is Saturday, Nov. 21. As reported by Signal Akron, owner Barbara Talevich opened the bakery in 1995, so this is its 32nd Thanksgiving season.

This year's menu leads with a Thanksgiving cake, a pumpkin cake with caramel cream cheese filling. The pies are apple, bumbleberry, sour cherry, strawberry rhubarb, pecan, chocolate cream, pumpkin and cranberry orange. Cheesecakes come in 6-inch and 10-inch sizes, in pumpkin, pumpkin praline and salted caramel. Pumpkin tiramisu comes as an individual serving or in 6-, 8- and 10-inch sizes. That range covers a household of two as well as a table of twelve. Pumpkin rolls come as full or half rolls.

The menu also has a cinnamon roll 6-pack in three flavors: brown sugar cranberry, sea salt maple and pumpkin spice cream cheese. That covers Thanksgiving morning or the weekend after. Large cut-out cookies come shaped as pumpkins, turkeys and fall leaves, alongside tea bread, molasses crinkles, oatmeal chai and pumpkin chocolate chip cookies, plus tea cookie trays.

Ask about prices and your pickup time when you call or stop in to order. The bakery's regular hours are Monday through Saturday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. If you'll be at the counter on Saturday anyway, the bakery has other favorites. In a Nov. 10 Beacon Journal piece, Talevich named the chocolate-chip cookie, carrot cake and New York-style cheesecake as longtime favorites and called the coconut macaroons a popular item.

Sunday, Nov. 22: D'Agnese's White Pond

A day later, the main course closes on White Pond Drive. D'Agnese's White Pond at 566 White Pond Drive sells Thanksgiving Take & Bake meals: $149 for four to six people or $279 for 10 to 12. Order by Nov. 22.

Each meal comes with a brined and roasted turkey, 2.5 pounds or 5 pounds depending on size, plus sage pan gravy, mashed Yukon gold potatoes, roasted root vegetables, cranberry sauce with orange and Italian herb bread dressing. It also has green beans with blistered tomatoes, a green salad with balsamic vinaigrette, and rolls with whipped maple butter. For dessert you choose pumpkin bread pudding with bourbon cream or fresh-filled cannolis. Add-ons include 2 pounds of carved turkey, 2 pounds of glazed spiral-sliced ham, cavatelli marinara, a quart of butternut squash bisque, and pumpkin or apple pie.

Pickup is Wednesday, Nov. 25, from 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. No other Wednesday pickup in the Beacon Journal roundup runs that late. The next latest is HoneyBaked at 7:30 p.m., and Waterloo Restaurant's pickups end at 4 p.m. If you work a full day before the holiday, you can stop on the way home. The order line is 234-678-3612.

Pies from West Side Bakery, ordered by Saturday, and dinner from D'Agnese's, ordered by Sunday, cover the whole meal from two West Akron kitchens.

Wednesday, Nov. 25: The last order windows and Thanksgiving Eve

Two grocery deadlines run all the way to the day before Thanksgiving. The Whole Foods Market store in Akron takes Thanksgiving orders through Nov. 25. A classic roast whole turkey meal for four is $99.99 and the meal for eight is $169.99, with mashed Yukon gold potatoes, herb stuffing, green beans, cranberry orange sauce and turkey gravy. Buehler's also takes Thanksgiving dinner orders through its Market Deli until Nov. 25. Dinner for two is $35.99, for six $79.99 and for 12 $149.99. The two-person dinner includes cranberry relish and two slices of pumpkin pie.

City Barbecue only needs 24 hours' notice for its turkey meals. Pickup is Thanksgiving morning from 9 a.m. to noon, so a Wednesday-morning order still makes the cutoff. Its turkey meals feed four to 25 people and cost $67.99 to $194.99.

Wednesday night has two events on West Market Street. At Tangier West, 3150 W. Market St., Hubb's Groove plays a Frankie Beverly and Freddie Jackson tribute at 7 p.m., followed by an after-party with a guest DJ. Mr. Zub's Deli & Bar at 795 W. Market St. has a Thanksgiving Eve indie dance party starting at 7:30 p.m., with drink specials and pizza. Call the venue about tickets and closing time before you go.

Thursday, Nov. 26: Dinner picked up or served the same day

If you're cooking on Thanksgiving and run short, or you'd rather not cook at all, a few options still work on the day itself.

In the Merriman Valley, Papa Joe's at 1561 Akron Peninsula Road sells Thanksgiving dinner carryout for pickup on the holiday. Each dinner is $27.99 and includes roast Ohio young turkey with stuffing, gravy, green beans, cranberry sauce, salad, and a choice of whipped potatoes or whipped yams. To order, call the Italian Market at 330-923-7999. The restaurant posts the menu on its Instagram page. Papa Joe's prices by the person, which makes it the simplest choice here for a household of one or two.

Buehler's orders are ready for pickup until 2 p.m. Thanksgiving Day. City Barbecue's pickup window ends at noon.

To eat out, the Tangier holds a Thanksgiving brunch buffet from 11 a.m. to 2:30 p.m., at $38 for adults and $18 for children 10 and younger. The buffet has roasted turkey with apple pecan stuffing, slow-roasted prime rib, chef-carved smoked Virginia ham, lobster-stuffed sole and vegetarian lasagna, plus seasonal pies and Bourbon Street bread pudding. Reserve at 330-376-7171. Farther out West Market into Montrose, Fleming's at 4000 Medina Road serves a two-course prix fixe starting at $64 per guest. The entrée choices are filet mignon, bone-in ribeye or roasted turkey breast, and seating begins at 11 a.m. Waterloo Restaurant on East Waterloo Road also runs a Thanksgiving Day buffet from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m., at $39.95 for adults and $17.95 for kids 10 and under. Call 330-773-5158 to reserve.

The order of operations

From today, the west side gives you this sequence: West Side Bakery pies by Saturday, a D'Agnese's dinner by Sunday, Whole Foods or Buehler's by Wednesday, and Papa Joe's or a buffet table on Thursday. Order the item with the earliest deadline first, which this week is dessert.

For more about the streets around these stops, start with our West Akron neighborhood guide or read how Highland Square keeps refilling its storefronts.

Hosting Thanksgiving tells you a lot about a house, from how the table fits to how many people the kitchen can handle at once. If this year's gathering has you wondering what your West Akron home is worth, Shelly Booth can give you a local read whenever you're ready. Start with a quick instant home valuation after the leftovers are put away.

Work With Shelly

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact her today.

Follow Shelly on Instagram